Jump To Navigation

Officer's belief that "something was not right" not enough to enter an apartment


September 23, 2009
Topic: Criminal

The Second DCA in Daytona Beach reaffirmed that police need more than a feeling to enter and search a home or apartment without a warrant. In the September 9, 2009 decision of Byrd. v. State, the court held that a police officer following a man into an apartment on the feeling that something was not right about the man's darting into said apartment was not an exigent circumstance sufficient to allow the police officer's entry. The United States Supreme Court has stated that either an emergency or other very limited exceptions allow a police officer's search without consent and without a warrant.

Because of the bad search, the evidence against the Defendant, namely a baggie of rock/crack cocaine was suppressed and the Defendant was ordered released. At Arnold & New, we litigate bad searches with a great deal of success in Florida and Georgia State and federal courts. If you need help with an arrest as a result of a police search, call our criminal defense lawyers at (904) 731-3800.

To read the opinion, click on the above link or read the full text below.


Certified | The Florida Bar | Criminal Trial Law

Arnold Law Firm, LLC

6279 Dupont Station Court
Jacksonville, FL 32217

Phone: 904-731-3800
Fax: 904-731-3807

E-mail Us | Map & Directions